WildJbSafari.cm

Free daily job search advice. 

Because it’s a jungle out there.

 

 

The Lion’s Pride: Interviewing

Negotiating With Mr. Smith, Part III: Smith vs. Jones vs. Greene

    

Contrary to popular wisdom, there are such things as good problems.  If your wallet is too small to hold all of your cash, for instance, that is a good problem.  So is having several employers bidding for your services.

 

Advertisement

 

Just like juggling three balls, though, if you lose your focus, you can drop them all. 

 

Let's assume for a moment that Mr. Smith, Ms. Jones and Mrs. Greene are extending employment offers.  For the sake of simplicity, let's also assume that other than pay, everything else is equal.  How do handle such a great problem?

 

A typical scenario would look like this:

 

Mr. Smith has offered you an annual salary $65,000.  You're successful in increasing that to $70,000, but ask for a day or two to consider the offer.

 

Ms. Jones offered you $70,000 later in the day.  Leverage Smith's offer to bump that amount up to, say, $75,000.  An easy way to do this is to be honest.  You could say something as simple as, "Thank you for the offer.  I'm sure this would be a mutually beneficial arrangement.  I am, however, weighing an offer from another employer for the same amount.  I'd like to give my decision the attention it deserves. I'll need a day or two to consider."

 

Mrs. Greene calls you the next day.  She's also prepared to offer $70,000.  Be up front with her, as well.  Disclose that you're currently weighing two other offers.  Odds are she will want to sway your decision by sweetening the pot.  Let's say she bumps the offer up to $80,000.  Again, thank her and tell her you will need a day or two to decide.

 

Now that you have three solid offers on the table, you've effectively given yourself a $15,000 annual raise from Mr. Smith's first offer to Mrs. Greene's most recent offer.  You may be leaving money on the table, however, if you jump at Mrs. Green's $80K.  Here are a few things to keep in mind to maximize your salary:

 

Be upfront about other offers.  This is your leveraging point.  One other offer may give you a raise, but two other offers usually mean a steep increase from the original offers.

 

Do NOT tell them who the offers are from.  It's a smaller world than you may think.  There's a significant chance that Smith, Jones and Greene have met each other.  If you give names, they will likely discuss their offers amongst themselves and decide as a group what price you'll get and who will get you.  This takes the power from you and gives it to them.

 

Make another lap.  Tell Mr. Smith you've gotten an offer for $80K and see if he wants to up the ante.  Do the same when talking to Jones and Greene.  Anything more than one lap and you'll be seen as greedy.

 

Decide and finalize. All things being equal, is money the only deciding point?  If so, you should have a clear winner after your last lap through.  After officially accepting Ms. Jones' new offer of $90,000, call Mr. Smith and Mrs. Greene to thank them, but you've decided to go in a different direction.  Show your professionalism by sending them both thank you notes.

 

Epilogue.  Stay in touch with Smith and Greene.  You may want to work with one of them in the future, and it's good to make sure there are no hard feelings from your negotiation processes.  Spring for an occasional coffee after hours.

 

IN THE CARAVAN: Leverage multiple offers by being up front with the number - and amount - of offers you have on the table, but do not disclose who they're from.  Maximize your offers by giving all parties a chance to give one more bid.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Google

 

Web

www.WildJobSafari.com

 

The Call of the Wild

Podcast

 

The Lion’s Pride

The Safari Guide

In the Field With…

The Daily Machete

 

Advertisement

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Resumes       Networking       Q & A       Adding Value

 

Interviewing

Negotiating Pay / The Questions You Hate to Answer / Nerves? Schmerves! /  Pre-Interview Prep /  Dress the Part / How to Show Your Portfolio / Speaking Of Pay...  / All Shapes and Sizes / Interview Practice / What To - And NOT To Reveal / Andre's Answers and Roger's Requests / Practice Like The Karate Kid / Building Rapport 101 / Be a S.T.A.R.  / Worst...Interview...Answers...Ever.  / The Five Most Important Questions for You to Ask / Reflecting for Rapport / 18 Questions You're Bound to Hear / The Phone Interview  / Negotiating With Mr. Smith, Part I / Negotiating With Mr. Smith, Part II: My Pete Rose for Your Reggie Jackson and Matchbox / Negotiating With Mr. Smith, Part III: Smith vs. Jones vs. Greene / Remove Thy Foot from Thy Mouth / Body Language 101 / Interviewing Disasters / Hire Your Boss / Keeping Your Cool Under Pressure / Returning the Question / The Dinner Interview / What You Want? Baby, You Know I Got It! / Know Your Industry / You Don’t Need to be a Psychic / Training / The Hippo Technique / Dropping Names / Marking Your Territory / The Walk-On Role / Body Language: The 15 Signals Hiring Managers Send and How to Read Them / You Have GOT to be KIDDING Me! / Taking a Drop: Re-Interviewing After the Fact / Proposing Your Own Job / Answering Self-Employment Questions: The Self-Employment Paradox